This is an outdated version published on 2024-12-27. Read the most recent version.

Vol. 3 No. 2 (2024)
Biopolitics

Articles

Totalitarianism or Biopolitics? Concerning a Philosophical Interpretation of the Twentieth Century

Published 2024-12-27

  • Esposito R.
    • ,
  • Zhuravlev M.

Abstract

In this article, Roberto Esposito addresses two opposing modes of philosophical interpretation of the twentieth century: the paradigm of totalitarianism and the paradigm of biopolitics. He argues that the philosophical basis of the paradigm of totalitarianism, as represented in the works of Hannah Arendt, Jacob Talmon, Raymond Aron, François Furet, Marcel Gaucher and Claude Lefort, is historicism, which aims to search for origins and assumes the continuity and directionality of history. The author points out a number of aporias inherent in this paradigm and concludes that the category of totalitarianism is logically inconsistent. As for the paradigm of biopolitics, it goes back to Nietzsche's genealogy, is developed by Foucault and implies the interpretation of history as a history of conflicts and overlaps between different vectors of meaning. Considering this paradigm, the author insists on the theoretical inconsistency of two conceptual fusions: on the one hand, Nazism and communism, on the other hand, liberalism and democracy.  Communism belongs to the philosophical tradition of the West, whereas Nazism — not political philosophy but rather political biology - falls out of it. According to Esposito, historically liberal democracy has never existed, and philosophically the concepts of democracy and liberalism are simply incompatible. He argues, firstly, that there is a certain cultural and linguistic affinity between Nazism and liberalism (in both cases, bios as the object and subject of politics is central) and, secondly, that communism should be seen as the paroxysmal completion of democracy. The author points to the impossibility of traditional democracy functioning under the conditions of the biopolitical turn and raises the question of what a new biopolitical democracy — or democratic biopolitics — might be.

Keywords

Array, Array, Array, Array, Array

PDF (Russian)

Author Biography

Esposito R.

Professor of Theoretical Philosophy at the Scuola Normale Superiore; Pisa, Italy

Zhuravlev M.

PhD student of the Faculty of Philosophy, Lomonosov Moscow State University; Moscow, Russia

References

  1. Del Noce A. L’Interpretazione transpolitica della storia contemporanea / Del Noce A. – Naples: Guida, 1982. – 47 p. – ISBN 9788870421613.
  2. Arendt H. Istoki totalitarizma [The Origins of Totalitarianism] / H. Arendt. – Moscow: TsentrKom, 1996. – 672 p. – ISBN 5-87129-006-X. (In Russian)
  3. Talmon J. L. The Origins of Totalitarian Democracy / J. L. Talmon. – London: Secker & Warburg, 1952. – 366 p.
  4. Furet F. Revolutionary France, 1770–1880 / F. Furet. – Oxford: Blackwell, 1992. – 630 p. – ISBN 978-0631170297.
  5. Furet F. The Passing of an Illusion: The Idea of Communism in the Twentieth Century / F. Furet. – Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1999. – 596 p. – ISBN 978-0226273419.
  6. Aron R. Opium intellektualov [The Opium of the Intellectuals] / R. Aron. – Moscow: AST, 2015. – 480 p. – ISBN 978-5-17-081909-6. (In Russian)
  7. Aron R. Democracy and Totalitarianism: A Theory of Political Systems / R. Aron. – Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 1990. – 262 p. – ISBN 978-0472064519.
  8. Aron R. Power, Modernity, and Sociology: Selected Sociological Writings / R. Aron / D. Schnapper (ed.). – London: Edward Elgar Publishing, 1988. – 234 p. – ISBN 978-1852780302.
  9. Gauchet M., Swain G. Madness and Democracy: The Modern Psychiatric Universe / M. Gauchet, G. Swain. – Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1999. – 360 p. – ISBN 978-0691033723.
  10. Gauchet M. La Révolution des pouvoirs: La Souveraineté, le peuple, et la représentation, 1789–1799 / M. Gauchet. – Paris: Gallimard, 1995. – 304 p. – ISBN 978-2070742974.
  11. Gauchet M. La Révolution des droits de l'homme / M. Gauchet. – Paris: Gallimard, 1989. – 341 p. – ISBN 2-07-071583-3.
  12. Lefort C. Writing: The Political Test / C. Lefort. – Durham: Duke University Press Books, 2000. – 312 p. – ISBN 978-0822325208.
  13. Lefort C. La Complication: Retour sur le communisme / C. Lefort. – Paris: Fayard, 1999. – 257 p. – ISBN 978-2213603155.
  14. Nolte E. Evropeiskaya grazhdanskaya voyna (1917–1945). Natsional-sotsializm i bol’shevizm [European Civil War (1917–1945). National Socialism and Bolshevism] / E. Nolte. – Moscow: Logos, 2003. – 528 p. – ISBN 5-8163-0046-6. (In Russian)
  15. Levinas E. Reflections on the Philosophy of Hitlerism / E. Levinas // Critical Inquiry. – 1990. – Vol. 17. – P. 62–71.
  16. Agamben G. Homo sacer. Suverennaya vlast’ i golaya zhizn’ [Homo Sacer. Sovereign Power and Bare Life] / G. Agamben. – Moscow: Izdatel’stvo «Evropa», 2011. – 256 p. – ISBN 978-5-9739-0202-5. (In Russian)
  17. Schmitt C. Dukhovno-istoricheskoe sostoyanie sovremennogo parlamentaryzma. Predvaritel’nye zamechaniya (O protivopolozhnosti parlamentaryzma i demokratii) [The Spiritual-Historical Condition of Contemporary Parliamentarism. Preliminary Remarks (On the Opposition of Parliamentarism and Democracy)] / C. Schmitt // Russian Sociological Review. – 2009. – Vol. 8. – No. 2. – P. 6–16. (In Russian)
  18. Esposito R. Terza persona: Politica della vita e filosofia dell’impersonale / R. Esposito. – Turin: Einaudi, 2007. – 184 p. – ISBN 978-8806187811.