Vol. 3 No. 2 (2024)
Biopolitics

Articles

Political Historicism of Michel Foucault

Published 2024-12-27 — Updated on 2024-12-28

  • Anton Prokopchuk

Anton Prokopchuk
Independent researcher

Abstract

The article explores the relation between historical knowledge and political philosophy of sovereignty in Michel Foucault's late work. The concept of «political historicism», introduced in «Society Must Be Defended» lectures, is analysed. This concept was not further developed by Foucault and thus has not attracted due attention in literature. However, its principles are incorporated into the genealogical method. According to Foucault, the classic theory of sovereignty initially articulated by Thomas Hobbes emerged as a counterweight to the historical-political discourse of seventeenth-century England. Although it includes the construct of «war of all against all», the historical factuality of war is not seen essential to the institution of political order. Historical knowledge is systematically disqualified from Hobbes’s theory, which Foucault examines in its polemical context. He states that Hobbes opposes contemporary political historicism, which insists that any political idea can only be understood as a weapon of a particular ideological struggle. Despite all the differences between variants of political historicism developed from 17th century onwards, this kind of discourse always presupposes a specific form of sociology. According to that, the structure of society is binary, as it is constantly being split apart by two conflicting groups. Political history is thus the history of war within society. Contrary to the classic theory of sovereignty, this sociology systematically opposes society and the state. Here the state is seen not as a product of social contract, but as a result of situational balance of powers, an instrument of continuation of the everlasting war within society by nonmilitary means. The article shows that Foucault not only studies political historicism as a form of historical knowledge, but also adheres to its principles in his own critique of sovereignty as a crucial component of the recent biopolitical dispositive. This is precisely the reason why among Foucault’s better-known studies in genealogy, «Society Must Be Defended» is the closest one to a purely sociological work. Therefore, the more thorough study of political historicism allows to rehabilitate a relatively less explored region of Foucault's oeuvre and to outline new productive ways of keeping his legacy relevant while acknowledging the shortcomings of his method.

Keywords

genealogy, Historismus, methodology of history, political theology, sociology, sovereignity

PDF (Russian)

Author Biography

Anton Prokopchuk

Master of Philosophy, independent researcher; Moscow, Russia.

References

  1. Groulx R. Michel Foucault, la politique comme guerre continuée / R. Groulx. – Paris: L’Harmattan, 2015. – 280 p. – ISBN 978-2343062266.
  2. Marks J. Foucault, Franks, Gauls. Il faut défendre la société: The 1976 Lectures at the Collège de France / J. Marks // Theory, Culture & Society. – 2000. – No. 17 (5). – P. 127–147.
  3. Meinecke F. Vozniknovenie istorizma [Historism: The Rise of a New Historical Outlook] / F. Meinecke. – Moscow: Centr gumanitarnyh iniciativ, 2024. – 480 p. – ISBN 978-5-98712-031-6. (In Russian)
  4. Troeltsch E. Istorizm i ego problemy [Historicism and Its Problems] / E. Troeltsch. – Moscow: Jurist, 1994. – 720 p. – ISBN 5-7357-0047-2. (In Russian)
  5. Rutkevich А. М. Nasledie istorizma [Heritage of Historicism] / А. М. Rutkevich // Filosofija. Zhurnal Vysshej shkoly jekonomiki. – 2020. – No. 4 (3). – P. 36–70. (In Russian)
  6. Vlasova O. A. Rozhdenie fukianskogo metoda: jepistemologija/fenomenologija, psihologija/psikhijatrija [The Birth of Foucault’s Method: Epistemology/Phenomenology, Psychology/Psychiatry] / O. A. Vlasova. // Logos. – 2019. – No. 29 (2). – P. 25–50. (In Russian)
  7. Veyne P. Fuko. Ego mysl' i lichnost' [Foucault, His Thought, His Character] / P. Veyne. – Saint Petersburg: Vladimir Dal', 2013. – 195 p. – ISBN 978-5-93615-135-4. (In Russian)
  8. Foucault M. Nuzhno zashhishhat' obshhestvo: Kurs lekcij, prochitannyh v Kollezh de Frans v 1975–1976 uchebnom godu [«Society Must Be Defended». Lectures at the Collège de France 1975–1976] / M. Foucault. – Saint Petersburg: Nauka, 2005. – 312 p. – ISBN 5-02-026848-8. (In Russian)
  9. Foucault М. Bezopasnost', territorija, naselenie. Kurs lekcij, prochitannyh v Kollezh de Frans v 1977-1978 uchebnom godu [Security, Territory, Population: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1977–1978] / М. Foucault. – Saint Petersburg: Nauka, 2011. – 544 p. – ISBN 978-5-02-037115-6. (In Russian)
  10. Foucault M. What is Critique? // Foucault M. The Politics of Truth / M. Foucault. – Los Angeles: Semiotext(e), 2007. – P. 41–82. – ISBN 978-0-226-38358-3.
  11. Foucault M. Society Must Be Defended. Lectures at the Collège de France 1975–1976 / M. Foucault – New York: Picador, 2003. – P. 336. – ISBN 978-0312422660.
  12. Hobbes T. Leviathan / T. Hobbes. – Revised stud. ed. – Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996. – 618 p. – ISBN 978-0521567978.
  13. Zarka Y. C. Foucault et le concept non juridique du pouvoir / Y. C. Zarka // Cités. – 2000. – No. 2. – P. 41–52.
  14. Filippov А. F. Ustrojstvo vlasti v «Leviafane» Tomasa Gobbsa [Mechanism of Power in Thomas Hobbes’s «Leviathan»] // Hobbes Т. Leviafan [Leviathan] / А. F. Filippov. – Moscow: Ripol-Klassik, 2020. – P. 5–34. – ISBN 978-5-386-09587-1. (In Russian)
  15. Zarka Y. C. Hobbes and Modern Political Thought / Y. C. Zarka. – Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2016. – 278 p. – ISBN 978-1474401210.
  16. Ivanova J. V., Sokolov P. V. Krome Dekarta: razmyshlenija o metode v intellektual'noj kul'ture Evropy rannego Novogo vremeni [Beyond Descartes: Discourses on the Method in Early Modern Intellectual Culture] / J. V. Ivanova, P. V. Sokolov. – Moscow: Kvadriga, 2011. – 304 p. – ISBN 978-5-91791-081-9. (In Russian)
  17. Harrington J. The Commonwealth of Oceana and A System of Politics / J. Harrington. – Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008. – 332 p. – ISBN 978-0521423298.
  18. Crano R. D. Genealogy, Virtuality, War (1651/1976) / R. D. Crano // Foucault Studies. – 2011. – No. 11. – P. 156–178.
  19. Pocock J. G. A. Bjork i drevnjaja konstitucija: ob odnoj probleme v istorii idej [Burke and the Ancient Constitution – a Problem in the History of Ideas] / J. G. A. Pocock // Filosofija. Zhurnal Vysshej shkoly jekonomiki. – 2018. – No. 2 (3). – P. 141–170. (In Russian)
  20. Pocock J. G. A. James Harrington and the Good Old Cause: a study of the ideological context of his writings / J. G. A. Pocock // The Journal of British Studies. – 1970. – No. 10 (1). – P. 30–48.
  21. Prokopchuk А. Neutopicheskij utopizm Dzhejmsa Harringtona [Non-utopian Utopianism of James Harrington] / А. Prokopchuk. – Text: digital // Gorky.media: [website]. – 2023. – 3 november. – URL: https://gorky.media/context/neutopicheskij-utopizm-dzhejmsa-harringtona (accessed: 20.09.2024). (In Russian)
  22. Foucault М. Omnes et singulatim: k kritike politicheskogo razuma [Omnes et Singulatim: Towards a Criticism of «Political Reason»] // Foucault М. Intellektualy i vlast': izbrannye politicheskie stat'i, vystuplenija i interv'ju. V 3 ch. Ch. 2 [Intellectuals and Power: Selected Political Papers, Lectures, and Interviews. In 3 Vol. Vol. 2] / M. Foucault. – Moscow: Praksis, 2005. – P. 285–319. – ISBN 5-910574-23-0. (In Russian)
  23. Foucault M. Il faut défendre la société. Cours au Collège de France (1975–1976) / M. Foucault. – Paris: Gallimard/Seuil, 1997. – 304 p. – ISBN 978-2020231695.
  24. Freyer H. Revoljucitja sprava [Revolution from the Right] / H. Freyer. – Moscow: Praksis, 2008. – 144 p. – ISBN 978-5-901574-71-3. (In Russian)
  25. Jünger E. Rabochij. Gospodstvo i geshtal't [The Worker. Dominion and Form] / E. Jünger. – Saint Petersburg: Nauka, 2000. – 539 p. – ISBN 5-02-026781-3. (In Russian)
  26. Nisbet R. A. De Bonald and the Concept of the Social Group / R. A. Nisbet // Journal of the History of Ideas. – 1944. – No. 5 (3). – P. 315–331.
  27. Dean M., Villadsen K. State Phobia and Civil Society. The Political Legacy of Michel Foucault / M. Dean, K. Villadsen. – Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2016. – 208 p. – ISBN 978-0804796972.
  28. Hannsen B. Critique of Violence / B. Hannsen. – London, New York: Routledge, 2000. – 324 p. – ISBN 978-0415223409.
  29. Foucault M. Nietzsche, la généalogie, l'histoire // Foucault M. Dits et écrits 2 / M. Foucault. – Paris: Gallimard, 1994. – P. 136–156. – ISBN 978-2070761869.
  30. Tully J. The pen is a mighty sword: Quentin Skinner’s analysis of politics // Tully J. Meaning and Context. Quentin Skinner and his Critics / J. Tully. – Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1988. – 370 p. – ISBN 978-0691077963.
  31. Skinner Q. Kollingvudovskij podhod k istorii politicheskoj mysli: stanovlenie, vyzov, perspektivy [The Rise of, Challenge to and Prospects for a Collingwoodian Approach to the History of Political Thought] / Q. Skinner // NLO. – 2004. – No. 66 (2). – P. 55–66. (In Russian)
  32. Pasquino P. Political Theory of War and Peace: Foucault and the History of Modern Political Theory / P. Pasquino // Economy and Society. – 1993. – No. 22 (1). – P. 77–88.
  33. Schmitt C. Politicheskaja teologija [Political Theology] // Schmitt C. Ponjatie politicheskogo [The Concept of the Political] / C. Schmitt – Saint Petersburg: Nauka, 2016. – P. 5–59. – ISBN 978-5-02-038400-2. (In Russian)
  34. Schmitt C. Ponjatie politicheskogo [The Concept of the Political] / C. Schmitt. – Saint Petersburg: Nauka, 2016. – P. 280–408. – ISBN 978-5-02-038400-2. (In Russian)
  35. Schmitt C. Gosudarstvo kak konkretnoe ponjatie, svjazannoe s opredelennoj istoricheskoj jepohoj [The State as a Concrete Concept, Bound to a Historical Epoch] / C. Schmitt // Logos. – 2012. – No. 89 (5). – P. 205–215. (In Russian)
  36. Adorno F. P. Fiction et histoire / F. P. Adorno // Cités. – 2000. – No. 2. – P. 83–96.
  37. Deleuze G. Peregovory [Negotiations 1972–1980] / G. Deleuze. – Saint Petersburg: Nauka, 2004. – 235 p. – ISBN 5-02-026845-3. (In Russian)