Vol. 4 No. 1 (2025)
From the Multiple Turn to Ontological Anarchy

Articles

Mountain, Water and Anarchy

Published 2025-06-30

  • Denis Shalaginov

Denis Shalaginov
Russian State University for the Humanities image/svg+xml

Abstract

The article is a detailed review of Yuk Hui’s book «Art and Cosmotechnics» (2021). The review opens with a consideraation of one of the major analytical decisions and conceptual innovations in Hui’s work: the division of recursive logic into tragist and Daoist one. The reviewer then focuses on Hui’s key concept of cosmotechnics, understood as the unification of the cosmic and moral order in technical activity, and points out how this concept is specified in «Art and Cosmotechnics». Reflecting on the need to clarify what is meant by «cosmos» in this context and how this cosmos relates to the function of art, the reviewer draws a line that in its own way supplements Hui’s approach: whereas Hui emphasizes recursivity (and unity), the reviewer emphasizes contingency (and not-one). This reaccentuation also leads to a shift from Hui’s claimed epistemological pluralism to ontological anarchism. After pointing to Hui’s general intension and clarifying both the function of aesthetic thinking and the understanding of the cosmos in the conception of cosmotechnics, the reviewer problematizes the aspect of Hui’s project consisting in the search for the universal, and for this purpose turns to an indigenous cosmo-aesthetics.

Keywords

recursivity, contingency, cosmotechnics, cosmos, art, epistemological pluralism, ontological anarchism, not-one

PDF (Russian)

Author Biography

Denis Shalaginov

PhD, senior research fellow of the Center for scientific research work of the department of scientific activity of RSUH. 125047, Russian Federation, Moscow, Miusskaya Square, bld. 6. 

References

  1. Hui Y. Post-Evropa [Post-Europe]. — Moscow: Ad Marginem, 2025. — 176 p. — ISBN: 978-5-91103-823-6. (In Russian).
  2. Simondon G. Individ i ego fiziko-biologicheskij genezis [The individual and its physical and biological genesis]. — Moscow: IOI, 2023. — 483 p. — ISBN: 978-5-7312-0916-8. (In Russian).
  3. Jullien F. Velikij obraz ne imeet formy, ili Cherez zhivopis’ — k ne-ob’’ektu [The Great Image Has No Form, or On the Nonobject through Painting]. — Moscow: Ad Marginem, 2014. — 368 p. — ISBN: 978-5-91103-184-8. (In Russian).
  4. Hui Y. Iskusstvo i kosmotekhnika [Art and cosmotechnics]. — Moscow: AST, 2024. — 384 p. — ISBN: 978-5-17-152584-2. (In Russian).
  5. Deleuze G. Marsel’ Prust i znaki. Stat'i [Marcel Proust and signs. Articles]. — Saint Petersburg: Laboratoriya metafizicheskih issledovanij filosofskogo fakul’teta SPbGU; Aletejya, 1999. — 190 p. — ISBN 5-89329-149-2. (In Russian).
  6. Heidegger M. Vremya i bytie [Time and being]. — Moscow: Respublika, 1993. — 447 p. — ISBN: 5-250-01496-8. (In Russian).
  7. Simondon G. Sut’ tekhnichnosti [The essence of technicity] // Sinij divan. — 2013. — No. 18. — pp. 93–114. (In Russian).
  8. Wittgenstein L. Logiko-filosofskij traktat [Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus] / L. Wittgenstein. — Moscow: Kanon + ROOI «Reabilitaciya», 2017. — 288 p. — ISBN: 978-5-88373-062-6. (In Russian).
  9. Hui Y. Vopros o tekhnike v Kitae. Esse o kosmotekhnike [The question concerning technology in China: an essay in cosmotechnics]. — Moscow: Ad Marginem, 2023. — 320 p. — ISBN: 978-5-91103-637-9. (In Russian).
  10. Latour B. Gde prizemlit’sya? Opyt politicheskoj orientacii [Where to land? The experience of political orientation]. — SPb.: Izdatel’stvo Evropejskogo universiteta v Sankt-Peterburge, 2019. — 202 p. — ISBN 978-5-94380-281-2.
  11. Clastres P. Obshchestvo protiv gosudarstva [Society against the state] // Stadis. — 2019. — No. 1. — pp. 38–54. (In Russian).
  12. Przedpełski R. Cosmic Hunt, Copper Electroplating, Chaosmic Transduction: Chaosmotechnics of Molecular Collaboration in Matthew Barney’s Redoubt Project (2016–21) // Text Matters. — 2023. — No. 13. — pp. 231–256.
  13. Pallotta J. Indigenous cosmo-aesthetics and cosmopolitics: From the Yanomami case // Alienocene. — 2025. — Stratum 15. — [Web resource]. — Available at: https://alienocene.com/2025/04/04/indigenous-cosmo-aesthetics-and-cosmopolitics-from-the-yanomami-case/. (Accessed: 28.05.2025).
  14. Viveiros de Castro E. Kannibal’skie metafiziki. Rubezhi poststrukturnoj antropologii [Cannibal metaphysics. Lines of a post-structural anthropology]. — Moscow: Ad Marginem, 2017. — 200 p. — ISBN: 978-5-91103-379-8. (In Russian).
  15. Mol A. Mnozhestvennoe telo: ontologiya v medicinskoj praktike [Body multiple: ontology in medical practice]. — Perm: Hyle Press, 2017. — 254 p. — ISBN: 978-5-9906611-7-2. (In Russian).
  16. Mechta o kosmotekhnike. Beseda Yuka Hueya i Evgeniya Kuchinova o tekhnologicheskih utopiyah [The Dream of Cosmotechnics. Yuk Hui and Eugene Kuchinov discuss technological utopias] // EastEast. – 2020. — [Web resource]. — Available at: https://easteast.world/posts/220. (Accessed: 28.05.2025). (In Russian).
  17. Bensusan H. Materializm, zabludivshijsya v lesah [Materialism lost in the woods] // lmnt. — 2021. — No. 2 — [Web resource]. — Available at: http://lmnt.space/portfolio/materialism-lost-in-the-woods/. (Accessed: 28.05.2025). (In Russian).
  18. Bensusan H. An-arché, Xeinos, urihi a: iznachal’nyj Drugoj v kosmopoliticheskom lesu [An-arché, Xeinos, urihi a: The Primordial Other in a Cosmopolitical Forest] // Neprikosnovennyj zapas. — 2022. — No. 3 (143). — pp. 117–138. (In Russian).
  19. Hui Y. Rekursivnost’ i kontingentnost’ [Recursivity and contingency]. — Moscow: V-A-C press, 2020. — 400 p. — ISBN: 978-5-907183-12-4. (In Russian).
  20. Bensusan H. Being up for Grabs: On Speculative Anarcheology. — London: Open Humanities, 2016. — 238 p. — ISBN 978-1-78542-029-0.
  21. Viveiros de Castro E. O modelyah i primerah: inzhenery i brikolery v antropocene [On Models and Examples: Engineers and Bricoleurs in the Anthropocene] // Neprikosnovennyj zapas. — 2022. — No. 3 (143). — pp. 59–87. (In Russian).